FRINGE Recap: 'Black Blotter' - Give Me My Remote : Give Me My Remote

FRINGE Recap: ‘Black Blotter’

December 15, 2012 by  

I…don’t even know where to start with Friday’s episode of FRINGE.

I suppose that’s a good thing, really. Right now my brain is everywhere and nowhere and very much still in the immediate “WTF did I just see?” phase, so my thoughts are incredibly jumbled. Which given what the heck we saw in “Black Blotter” feels fairly appropriate.

Previously, FRINGE showrunner J.H. Wyman had teased that “episode 9 is more along the lines of what we did in the 19 spot. It’s off the beaten track, but it also has significant reveals,” so I had been expecting something slightly out of the norm. And with the promos showing Walter tripping — and imagining a fairy — I figured there would be quirk. That being said, it’s possible “Black Blotter” was the farthest out there the show has actually gone…because we got to experience Walter’s drugged out brain, thanks to his impatience over being unable to remember key elements to the plot.

The main guide to the madness was Carla Warren, Walter’s lab assistant who died in 1991 (which was what led to his institutionalization), who spent much of the hour taunting her former boss about him being unable to remember what was essential and the fact that he was doomed to turn back into the man that he once was. While tripping, Walter was led to a journal of his old work, “went” to the Observer precinct, and saw countless surreal things and, oh, yeah, was transported into an animation sequence that was so unreal, I almost wish there had been a camera on my face to capture the “WHAT AM I SEEING ON MY TELEVISION SCREEN RIGHT NOW?!?” look. Walter Bishop, I will miss you so much.

Elsewhere, after Donald’s radio turned on, Peter and Olivia spent most of the episode tracking down the signal, eventually finding the origin spot — where a couple was taking care of the wee Observer (whom his parents had named “Michael”) who had vanished from the pocket universe. Our team was prompted for a password in order to gain the couple’s trust, and Walter realized his drugged out state had reminded him of what the code was: “black umbrella.” The couple, knowing what was in store for the boy they had raised for 20 years, said goodbye to their son and let him go off to fulfill his destiny.

Back at the lab, Peter and Olivia took care of the wee Observer, and Olivia asked him if he remembered her. He nodded his head, and Peter wondered how that was possible since their meeting with him happened in another timeline. Olivia explained it away as Observers experiencing time differently, but…I’m wondering if that was foreshadowing.

But, for me, what made the episode was the final Walter scene. He sat, broken, on the floor of his lab as memories washed over him. In a beautifully executed scene, we watched as 2036!Walter observed as 1986!Walter said goodbye to his son, crossed over, was lectured by Carla, and then lost his son again. The scenes played out in front of Walter’s face and it felt like one of the most beautifully handled scenes the show has done so far. Walter opted to burn his journal, and while Carla mocked him, the Nina who had popped up on occasion for this journey seemed to think he should keep fighting.

The depressingly romantic exchange of the night:

Peter: You amaze me. After everything I put you through, I did the very thing I promised you I wouldn’t do: I left you again. I’m more than a little embarrassed, you know.
Olivia: Peter, you don’t have to say anything.
Peter: I do. I don’t deserve you. I’m just so lucky. I’m so incredibly lucky to have you.

And while that was romantic, it also made me really sad. Was Peter wrong to put the tech in his body? Heck yes. But they’re also a team, a partnership. Heck, they are married and were raising a kid together pre-ambering…I would hope Peter no longer felt like he wasn’t worthy of Olivia. (And the same for her.) They’ve been through the trenches together, they’ve each had their ups and down moments and it shouldn’t be an issue of “deserving” anymore.

Other thoughts, theories, etc.

  • No, seriously, who the heck is Donald? At this point, I feel like it can’t be anyone we don’t already know, and several potential candidates seem to have been crossed out…
  • RIP Sam Weiss. I think. (Never forget, “Don’t trust Sam Weiss.”)
  • Should we take Walter not knowing Sam at face value or is it possible his drug haze made him confused?
  • Seeing those “Peter” scenes reminded me we’ll probably never really get into the backstory of original timeline Nina and Walter. (Which makes sense given the limited time.) Sad, though.
  • FRINGE has never been (nor never should be) about purely kicking butt, but it’s nice to see our team win one every once and awhile.
  • This may be absolutely overanalyzing things, but I found it fascinating Carla was dressed in white, a color typically deemed “innocent,” whereas Nina was in black, a color typically deemed more dark/evil…and yet their influences were the opposite of that. Carla was bringing out the worst in him, pushing him to discover the things that could be harmful and destructive, and yet Nina was encouraging him to ignore that and was a cheerleader of sorts. Possible it was just a random costume decision?
  • FRINGE may be the best show currently on TV using the flashback trope. Between the Peter flashes that preceded him taking out the Observer tech last week to Walter flashing back to “Peter,” they show has woven them in beautifully.
  • John Noble (Walter) remains incredible.
  • So far, there seems to be no lasting impact to Peter’s time as an Observer…
  • Within the first 5 minutes of the episode, I was once again so impressed with how much the show respects its audience. Bringing Carla back was a fantastic nod to the show and its history (after all, her death was first brought up in the pilot episode), and instead of them hitting you over the head with it (and ruining the surprise for those who didn’t see the promos), they trusted you’d know enough about her to get by.
  • On that note, here’s where the episode got tricky for me: one of the things that FRINGE has always done best is dig into its own mythology and bring up things you wouldn’t expect/recontextualize what you already know. But that game is considerably less fun right now (at least for me) because we’re not playing with a full deck. We know what Peter and Olivia know. (For the most part, because there were still several years pre-ambering we missed.) We know what transpired before Walter crossed over to get this timeline’s Peter and we know what happened since Peter returned and the bits and pieces we’ve found out about those years since then. Everything else is questionable. It’s hard to tap into the emotions we should feel based on a timeline we don’t even know for certain is real. (And no, the argument that everything happened the same, it just happened without Peter — we’ve seen the differences, both big and small. Olivia killer her stepfather in this timeline. William Bell and David Robert Jones were still alive. Who knows what else has been undone?)
  • The wee Observer/Michael’s father’s speech about his “son”  being “meant for something great” and that he was important…Walter foreshadowing?
  • I loved that we only heard music as the wee Observer said goodbye to his “parents.”

And in case you want to watch that trippy animated sequence again, enjoy…


Enough from me…what did you think of “Black Blotter”?

Follow @GiveMeMyRemote and @marisaroffman on Twitter for the latest TV news. Connect with other TV fans on GIVE ME MY REMOTE’s official Facebook page.

And to be the first to see our exclusive videos by subscribing to our YouTube channel at

Filed under Fringe Recap


9 Responses to “FRINGE Recap: ‘Black Blotter’”

  1. Jim on December 15th, 2012 6:35 am

    John Noble was just WOW! he truly proved that awards mean nothing. that man is just beyond exceptional! Going to miss seeing him on tv!
    Totally agree about Peter in that polivia scene, I hope the same for him, I thought I was the only one who thought that about Peter when he said it to Olivia, glad to see i wasn’t the only one! he’s only human, and he lost his child twice, as a father myself, I would have done the same thing. Also all the Nina/Carla scenes were just brilliant.
    Great recap/review as always. Thanks!

  2. Donna on December 15th, 2012 7:38 am

    But there does seem to be something wrong with Peter… he complained of “another one of those headaches,” and he can’t sleep.

  3. Sandy on December 15th, 2012 9:32 am

    Yeah I’m not sure how to think about Peters scene but I think I get him. I can understand him feeling this way. Remember he was lying to Olivia for awhile and this was his way of apologizing. I don’t think he feels he doesn’t deserve her.

  4. Marisa Roffman on December 15th, 2012 1:12 pm

    @Donna: True. That could be foreshadowing, or it could be the results of him (I’d imagine painfully) removing tech that had implanted into his brain. But given how the show has taken a break after every big “moment” (Peter’s Observer tech being mostly glossed over in “TtLGaWWFT,” Walter and Nina’s pact being unaddressed in “THK”), it wouldn’t surprise me at all if there was a Peter twist about the device removal in episode 10.

  5. Ray Roberson on December 15th, 2012 2:05 pm

    RE: Animation sequence => Awwww, homage to “Monty Python Flying Circus” – especially, “The Foot”!

  6. Jeff Sack on December 16th, 2012 12:18 am


    What are your thoughts that Michael, Donald or possibly both be September? We have yet to see him this season and I do expect he will be involved somehow in the storyline. Could Michael, actually be a younger version of September? Could Walter have referred to September as Donald for some reason? Perhaps the most creative episode the series has had and that says a lot. Great post!

  7. Denis on December 16th, 2012 10:18 pm

    Marisa, great write-up, as usual. A great shout out to Terry Gilliam/Monty Python, too. Interesting that the seahorse has appeared much more this season in a non-glyph context.
    Many people are hopping on the ‘Michael is September’ bus. I’m not so sure (although we hear September’s voice in next week’s preview.) Either way, I’m definitely starting to think that it will all end in January with some sort of massive (pun intended) time reset.
    Whenever Donald is mentioned, I keep thinking back to 2.08, the Donald who is sent by September to ‘clean up’ the irregularity created by August. He had a comm device from the Observers, yet a regular gun. He was felled by Peter using August’s gun, but we never had confirmation that he was actually dead, or what his connection to the Observers might have been. Maybe I’m overthinking this one.

  8. Marisa Roffman on December 17th, 2012 11:00 am

    @Jeff: I love the thought that Michael or Donald could possibly be September. There was a chilling shot at the end of “Inner Child” when the wee Observer passed by September would have SO MUCH MORE WEIGHT if that kid grew into September. And, of course, if September needed to move around in present day/be stealth, I could see him being told to put on a wig and be given a code name.

    @Denis: I was thinking about that, and given that Peter didn’t exist in this timeline, who knows how that episode played out…while the show loves to wink at its audience, I wonder if they’d name Donald if it WAS that Donald. (And I’d be amused if it was THAT SIMPLE.)

  9. DJSH on December 17th, 2012 12:30 pm

    Where can I find all the credits for the episode? I really want to know who played the fairy (never got a good look), etc.