MY BOYS Season Finale - Who Did P.J. Choose? - Give Me My Remote : Give Me My Remote

MY BOYS Season Finale – Who Did P.J. Choose?

September 11, 2007 by  

MY BOYS Season Finale - Who Did P.J. Choose?

Did any of you watch the season finale of MY BOYS last night?  If you did, please tell me you screamed at the TV like I did when the show faded to black before we got to see who P.J. brought along to Italy with her? Ugh, I’m dying!  Another fantastic season finale of this show!!

Good news for us (and I suppose them, but more us) – MY BOYS was just picked up for another season.  No word yet on when we will see new episodes, but once I know…you’ll know.

But back to the matter at hand – who do you think P.J. invited along to Italy?

My guesses after the jump…

My Guesses…
Ok, so I think that it’s either Bobby or Brendan.

Brendan – Based on P.J.’s almost revelation that she knew who she wanted to be there, I think it could be Brendan.  After their kiss at the end of last year’s half-season finale, I don’t think P.J. every really let go of her feelings for her best friend. Perhaps that was why she was pushing Thorn, the baseball player (can we just call him Keith?), and Evan back – she still has feelings for Brendan.

Bobby – There’s been no real sexual tension or more-than-platonic chemistry between P.J. and Bobby since they hooked up in the first few episodes.  I wasn’t really thinking it was him until P.J.’s “mystery man” upgraded her to first class.  We all know Bobby is richer than rich and could easily spring for the luxury accommodations.  But, Bobby…really?

Filed under My Boys


42 Responses to “MY BOYS Season Finale – Who Did P.J. Choose?”

  1. MY BOYS Season Finale - Who Did P.J. Choose? — All This Nonsense on September 11th, 2007 9:33 am

    […] reading this post by: Give Me My Remote For more… RSS […]

  2. Jo on September 11th, 2007 9:37 am

    It’s killing me not to know. I was thinking Thorn b/c of the upgrade. A man who’s flown as much as him would know the beauty of first class on international flights. But I’m with you, hoping that it’s Brendan.

  3. kilwiggle7 on September 11th, 2007 9:39 am

    oooo, i didn’t even think it could be Bobby… the whole upgrade thing could totally be Thorne, even though I wish it wasn’t.

    I’d be much happier if it was Brendan or Bobby (now that you mentioned it). During the whole poker game talk on who PJ should bring, Brendan took a back seat and then piped up at the very end. That and he didn’t play much of a role in the entire rest of the episode, so I’m thinking it is him… well, i hope it’s him 🙂

  4. Tippy on September 11th, 2007 9:48 am

    I screamed at the TV. I even rewound my DVR to make sure I didn’t miss something. I think it is Brendan too. Maybe he got a bonus at the radio station. I am so glad the show was picked up for another season. The writing is fantastic and it stays true to Chicago. My city looked so awesome during the “Day off”.

  5. AmyK on September 11th, 2007 9:51 am

    I loved the finale but found myself saying outloud (to no one in particular), “Oh, that is not nice.” at the end! It really could be any of those guys on the plane.

    I think it will be one of the three potential boyfriends only because that will fuel a lot of story lines for next season….how
    “the boys” will handle a serious boyfriend of P.J.’s., etc. They haven’t explored that yet.

    This show has really grown on me. I have always loved the guys but thought that P.J. was alittle annoying. She is more likeable now. Plus, you gotta love anything filmed in or about Chicago…

  6. RC on September 11th, 2007 9:55 am

    I hope its not Thorn. The two of them have no chemistry and his character is a bit boring. I also thought of Bobby. Perhaps because he’s the one I would choose. I’ve always been bothered by the fact that he and PJ hooked up in the first season and that was it. I’d settle for the baseball player too.

    Can I just say, as a suburban Chicago resident, that last night’s episodes were so fun to watch! I love this show. It is one of the few shows my husband will watch with me. I hope we don’t have to wait too long for next season.

  7. Annie C on September 11th, 2007 10:06 am

    I think it was Bobby because the episode seemed to be a plethora of reveals of Bobby’s character. They hint that he did take over the foundation, show all this adventure and insight, and that he is a slight commitment-phobe (just like PJ).

  8. Jess M on September 11th, 2007 10:21 am

    I screamed at the TV too. What a huge cliff-hanger! But I hope she chose Brendan. It seemed strange that after last season’s finale, they didn’t do much more with that story line. I was a little disappointed that they didn’t do anything more with that. Although, with the upgrade to first class, I can see Bobby or Thorn, too…

  9. Emily on September 11th, 2007 10:22 am

    I actually think she took her brother. PJ was so intent on being in Italy with no romantic attachments. Plus, Andy had just sold the boat and with his mini mid life crisis, a trip to Italy would be good for him.

    I seriously doubt it was Brendan. There was nothing in the episode to suggest the PJ would invite him. And as for the three other guys, she said she’s going to call them when she gets back, I believe her.

  10. carly f. on September 11th, 2007 10:22 am

    i also thought it was brendan in the beginning but then as soon as there was an upgrade, i changed it to bobby because of the moola….damn cliffhanger!!! especially when stephanie goes, “who is it?” haha

  11. Lisa on September 11th, 2007 10:33 am

    I really liked this episode! Did we know before that her real name is Penelope? I think that the former Cub and Evan would definitely not know that. Which makes it seem that it must be someone from her circle of friends!

  12. jmurae on September 11th, 2007 10:34 am

    I definitely don’t think it is any of the three that showed back up last night. I really want it to be Brendan because they never really finished that storyline. It was like, he acted weird and then he got a new girlfriend and that was it. I would also, LOVE it if she took Andy because how great would Fun Andy be in Italy?

  13. Give Me My Remote on September 11th, 2007 10:35 am

    I considered that she brought Andy as well, but PJ was so distraught and seemed so dreamy up in first class that it would almost be too creepy if it was her brother.

    Plus, he has got a little one at home, he’s moving, and he and Meredith are expecting so it would be pretty ballsy of him to leave all that behind and head to Italy.

    I also think it would be weird it were one of the three new guys – Hi, we’ve only been on 1-3 dates but I’d like to take you on a trip to Italy…bizarre!

    GOOD POINT on the guy knowing her name was Penelope – that had to be a clue, right? Someone that really knows her?

  14. Emily on September 11th, 2007 10:43 am

    Im sure her ticket said Penelope…the guy wouldn’t necessarily need to know.

  15. Annie D. on September 11th, 2007 10:44 am

    I think it was Bobby or the Cubs player (Keith from Scrubs). I somehow didn’t pick up on the Penelope thing.

  16. mg714 on September 11th, 2007 10:47 am

    I also loved the finale – great ending and wonderful scenes in Chicago. I love that they integrate so much of Chicago/the ‘burbs into the show! I also didn’t catch the thing with the flight attending asking for Penelope – I think Thorn might have known her real name, but probably not Evan or the cute Cub. Though I would like to see it be Brendan – I think the way they tried to resolve that storyline at the beginning of the season was too easy. Though, I kind of feel that way about how they dealt with her and Bobby as well!

  17. Merrie on September 11th, 2007 11:14 am

    OMG, I was so angry at my TV last night!

    I immediately thought it was her brother, but then realized she wouldn’t be all mushy if it was Andy. Then I thought about Bobby because they just kind of left that storyline hanging and who else has the money to make an upgrade like that? I mean, why would PJ and the former Cubs guy get together if he’s going to be in Milwaukee next season ? And I just didn’t get the Evan or Thorn chemistry. It’s not there. (BTW, Lance is cute. Go Stephanie!) And the idea of Brendon (Brendan?) is nice, but he has a girlfriend. I’m kind of glad they didn’t explore that because it would totally change the whole show if she started dating her best friend.

    Darn you, TBS! This show better get renewed! I love it! I have some problems with the premise, being a journalist and married to a sports writer (he doesn’t have the free time PJ seems to have), so the unethical things PJ does gets to me, but I love the show, so I’ll let it go.

  18. Jo on September 11th, 2007 11:53 am

    Ok now I’m leaning towards Brendan. PJ never got all mushy with Bobby. It was just a physical attraction. But remember at the poker table that Brendan and PJ excitedly retold about some trip they had taken together….and also when Stephanie explained to PJ how she had dropped the ball by answering her cell phone right after the kiss (something i totally would’ve done. d’oh!)…I could see PJ being more mushy about Brendan than Bobby.

    I am SO ready for them to write her with a steady for a while. To see her reaction and the guys’ reactions.

  19. jenn on September 11th, 2007 12:01 pm

    I hope it is Brendan and I could see that it could possibly be Bobby, because of the upgrade to first class.

    Did Bobby and PJ hook-up? Apparently, I missed this. Someone, please clue me in.

    I LOVED the whole Ferris’ Day off thing! I love that movie.

    Cliffhangers hurt my head!

  20. Ashley on September 11th, 2007 12:40 pm

    I’m really hoping it’s Bobby. He is so adorable and I know if I had a choice, I would totally take Bobby. PJ and Brendan just seem awkward to me.

    Oh and Bobby and PJ hooked up last season when she still technically had that boyfriend (forget his name). They were covering an away game and both drank at the bar and then we see them in bed together.

  21. Tunalicious27 on September 11th, 2007 1:39 pm

    I vote Brendan. But I really like seeing Jeremy Sisco on the show. However, since his character dissed her for his fiance before, I don’t vote for them as a couple. He had his chance and passed.

  22. Jennifer on September 11th, 2007 3:23 pm

    I love, love, LOVE My Boys!! Dang the stupid cliffhanger though!! At first I thought it was Andy also, but she seemed entirely too dreamy-eyed to be looking at her brother. I hope it was Bobby. He certainly has the money to up-grade her seat to first class =)

  23. tessahessa on September 11th, 2007 4:32 pm

    I am thinking it was Brendan. The whole Chicago tour was very ‘show Brendan what he doesn’t know he is missing.’ I could see Brendan being asked, but not being quite sure, and asking Bobby about it. I think Bobby may have given Brendan the money for the upgrade, or at least given him the idea to do it. Also, the fact that she only consulted herself for what she already knew would seem to support the fact that they have been delicately advancing the jealousy/latent feelings thing throughout the season that ties in all the way from the unresolved kiss and subsequent blow off.

    Also, they have had a great trip before, and you never forget someone who was easy to travel with. They are worth their weight in gold.

    And I love, love, love this show. And if I were going, I would choose Bobby – what about the rest of you?

  24. Hilary on September 11th, 2007 7:50 pm

    Okay, YES I did scream “NO!” at the tv when it faded to black. And yes, it was a GREAT season finale.

    My guess is Brendan too. I think for some reason it was Brando, just I don’t know. It just seems logical for some reason.

    So yeah, now I’m anxiouly waiting until I know the date when season3 preimeres. And I hope to have another one day marathon, but with the 2 seasons.

  25. Jen on September 11th, 2007 9:08 pm

    I haven’t seen it yet (I’m in a hotel and didn’t realize the cable was on est time). All of your talk makes me so excited to watch it. I recently started watching and really enjoy it. =-)

  26. genwithaG on September 12th, 2007 12:26 am

    I just have to say that I’m so excited this many people watch My Boys!! It’s so hard to find people who love it on the net.

    Anyways, my theory WAS that it had to be either Brendo or Thorn because I thought that she was serious enough with both of them to actually tell them her real first name, cuz if my name was Penelope, I don’t think that’s something I’d tell everyone. (Hopefully I didn’t just offend any Penelopes out there…)

    But now that I read Emily’s comment, it is true that the stewardess was probably just reading her name off the ticket. Damn! Now I have no clue!! I think Brendon would be too obvious, but I still have no clue.

    Also, I think I have to move to Chicago because obviously it is just overflowing with hot single guys!

  27. magstress on September 12th, 2007 10:58 am

    I really think that it is Thorn. She didn’t even seem to consider taking Evan or the Cub to Italy and then seemed to start wavering after her encounter with him. The fact that she held off on telling her friends about running into him made me think that it must have had a big impact on her.

  28. Dale on September 12th, 2007 6:12 pm

    Does anyone know the painting that they showed us during the tour of Chicago. I really want to buy a poster.

    If you know, please email me.


  29. Sylvie on September 14th, 2007 1:10 pm

    I dont think its Branden. That’s kind of too obvious, cause of course we are all rooting for him. Plus to end both seasons with a Brenden cliffhanger? That isnt very nice of the writers.
    After much consideration (and hair pulling i might add) my guess is on Bobby. I mean a first class ticket to Italy does scream “Balla” lol. =) And we all know that he is pretty loaded.

  30. luce on September 21st, 2007 3:10 pm

    it’s got to be hank. not obvious and stephanie brought him up.

  31. Juliana on October 28th, 2007 6:50 pm

    Brendan? That sounds like last season all over again… Plus, where would Brendan get the money to upgrade two coach tickets to first class? I hope it’s not him. I’d settle for the cute cub… Or even Bobby…

  32. Kirsten on November 20th, 2007 3:15 am

    I really hope it’s Brendan. I agree with Steph, they would make a cute couple. I hate the idea of PJ dating any other guy. It can’t be Bobby because he earns his own money, he just lives in the sweet apartment. The cub guy is ugly and gross, and Hank is wrong for PJ. The Botanist is just so boring, I mean, he studies plants-how boring can you get. Hold on, it’s probably the cub guy cuz she told him… oh yuck.

  33. Natty on April 1st, 2008 10:44 pm

    First of all, I totally screamed to the TV!! Of course at first there will be a little mystery about whom did PJ take, but I think it probably wont be anyone like Brendan or Bobby, I think it will be someone unexpected like Mike or something. But i hope not, tha would be a little dull ! 😉
    About the second season i haven’t heard any news, just something about a delay of the dvd of the first season, and that leading to a delay of the second season; all due to the strike. If anybody knows anything, please post it!

  34. Sarah on April 7th, 2008 6:16 pm

    I know.. the cliffhanger pissed me off sooo much. T.V. can be a bitch. Seriously though i really think it’s either Bobby or Brendan. Because if you think about it both story lines with p.j and bobby, P.J. and Brendan never made sense, and kinda left us hanging. It’ll suck if she chooses the three guys she’ll “call when she gets back” because that would be a little boring, plus Evan never got along with any of the guys…personally i’m hoping it’s bobby. Especially since they did sleep that was a shocker lol!!

  35. flower on April 27th, 2008 11:11 pm

    i really think the same that you do..for the same reason…but i think that if i have to pick one it will be brendan…their story wasnt even starting and the writers put it on hold…

    after doing her “thinking” pj sure realize her feelings for him..

  36. tori on May 28th, 2008 4:03 pm

    im kinda thinking it is evan … cause thorn and the cub wanted to go but evan didnt say anything about going with her he just knew she was going. and u know its none of the boys cause they really wanted to go and she was really worried that the person didnt show up. the cub and thorn wanted to go with her evan didnt say anything about going so i can see her maybe not sure if he would show up or now thats why she was so freaked that he didnt show at first.

  37. ale on August 3rd, 2008 8:17 pm

    someone knows the name of the episode ok PJ and brandon’s kiss? please if you can help me ’cause i could’t watchh it so i`m looking for it

  38. weight loss on September 26th, 2015 11:18 pm

    I have read a few good stuff here. Certainly price bookmarking for revisiting. I wonder how much effort you set to make this sort of excellent informative website.

  39. 3216031588160132157815871585157615751578321605161015751607321576157516041585161015751590 on October 2nd, 2015 2:42 am

    Strong blog. I acquired several nice information. I?ve been keeping a watch on this technology for some time. It?utes attention-grabbing the method it retains completely different, nonetheless a lot of of the primary components remain a similar. have you observed a lot change since Search engines designed their own latest purchase in the field?

  40. Filipino Movies on October 31st, 2015 2:22 am

    It has always been my belief that very good writing like this takes research and talent. It’s extremely apparent you’ve got done your homework. Great job!

  41. Malik Henley on November 3rd, 2015 10:39 am

    I am glad to be one of a lot of visitors on this excellent web site (:, thanks for posting .

  42. vermikompost nedir on November 15th, 2015 1:52 am

    Thank you pertaining to giving this outstanding content material on your web-site. I discovered it on google. I may check back again should you publish extra aricles.